Having it be THAT tight is going to be tough on the barrel, and temperature changes (which all hunting calls are going to go through) are going to mess some things up.
Put the end of the call TIGHT on the palm of your hand. Then, blow through the call. I think you will find there is air escaping around the insert.
My opinion, you need to make things fit to where the o-rings are doing their job of creating an air-tight, yet "sponge" fit.
Parker