Well, I listened to the sound file several dozen times. To my ear, it is way too high pitched to be a howler. And this was the point I was making with him.
I would have been quite unhappy with that call had I bought it and
1) I heard the sound.
2) I got to see how SMALL it is. The horn is not over 4" long. That is way too short to make a decent howler.
And yes, the statement that the tone board makes the sound not the horn was silly. Yes, the toneboard plays an important role, but the horn, both in length and width, thickness, all have an effect on the sound.
A tone board that breaks on a call that size, with that big of a bore, would surely break badly on a call with a 3/4 or 5/8" bore call because the tone board has inherant flaws in it. I have several anler open reeds that do not break anywhere, and to try and sell a call that "isn't too bad" for that kind of money is why most calls today sell for far less than they should. The market is flooded with good wood turners who have yet to master the craft of making calls.
I just quit responding to the thread. I think the sound file says it all, and justifies my position. I am sure that if someone buys that call they are going to be quite dissapointed with not only the sound, but the size of the call.
Al @ THO